The Metrics of Value: Decoding the Vietnam Coffee Grading System (e.g., TCVN 4193:2014) for Global Buyers

In our previous deep dive into the upper echelons of the market, we explored the rigorous agronomy required for Organic green coffee beans certification. We established that obtaining an organic certificate is a testament to a farmer’s dedication to soil health and chemical-free production. However, a certificate tells you how a bean was grown; it does not tell you how it will roast, nor does it guarantee the physical uniformity required for industrial consistency.

You can have a fully certified Organic bean that is physically uneven, riddled with broken pieces, or dangerously high in moisture. To bridge the gap between “sustainable” and “marketable,” we must speak the language of physics and geometry. We must master the Vietnam coffee grading system (e.g., TCVN 4193:2014).

For the professional Vietnamese green coffee beans supplier, this standard is the contract’s backbone. For the buyer, it is the tool used to hold that supplier accountable. Whether you are sourcing a premium “Robusta Honey” or a commercial bulk container for soluble production, understanding TCVN 4193:2014—the Vietnam National Standard for Green Coffee—is essential for defining value, negotiating price, and ensuring the final cup quality.

This guide is your technical manual. We will deconstruct the grading parameters of Vietnam’s coffee sector, moving beyond the simple “Grade 1” label to analyze screen sizing, defect counting protocols, and the critical moisture metrics that define a successful export contract.

---

The Architecture of the Vietnam Coffee Grading System (e.g., TCVN 4193:2014)

The Vietnam coffee grading system (e.g., TCVN 4193:2014) is not merely a suggestion; it is the codified language of the trade. Adopted to align Vietnamese production with international standards (like ISO 10470), it categorizes coffee based on three primary pillars:

1. Physical Dimensions: The size of the bean (Screen Size).
2. Visual Integrity: The presence of defects (Black, Broken, Foreign Matter).
3. Chemical Stability: The moisture content.

While the market often uses shorthand like “G1” or “G2,” a professional contract must reference the specific tolerances allowed within these grades.

Why “TCVN” Matters to the Buyer

When you receive an offer sheet from a supplier in Dak Lak, and it reads “Robusta S18,” that designation is meaningless without the regulatory context. Does S18 mean 100% of beans are on the screen? Or 90%? TCVN 4193:2014 provides the answer (usually a 5-10% tolerance for undersize). Without referencing this standard in your contract, you leave the “allowable margin of error” open to interpretation—a risk no serious buyer should take.

---

Pillar 1: Grading by Screen Size (The Geometry of Roasting)

In the Vietnam coffee grading system (e.g., TCVN 4193:2014), size equals value. This is based on the roasting principle that beans of uniform size transfer heat at a uniform rate. Mixing large and small beans leads to uneven roasting (some charred, some under-developed).

Vietnam uses a round-hole sieve system, measured in 1/64ths of an inch (though often converted to millimeters).

The Commercial Hierarchy

When sourcing from a top-tier Vietnamese green coffee beans supplier, you will typically encounter these three primary classifications:

1. Screen 18 (The “King” Grade)

• Diameter: ≥ 7.10 mm.
• Market Position: This is the premium export grade. It commands the highest differential. The beans are bold, dense, and offer the best visual presentation for whole-bean retail.
• Buying Tip: A standard “Screen 18” contract allows for 10% of beans to fall through to Screen 16. To secure a truly premium lot, negotiate a “90% on Screen 18” clause.

2. Screen 16 (The “Standard” Grade)

• Diameter: ≥ 6.30 mm.
• Market Position: The workhorse of the Vietnamese export industry. It is excellent for blends and high-volume roasting where visual “boldness” is less critical than price, but uniformity is still required.

3. Screen 13 (The “Industrial” Grade)

• Diameter: ≥ 5.00 mm.
• Market Position: Often used for soluble (instant) coffee production. These beans are small but can still be flavor-dense. However, they are often harder to roast evenly in drum roasters.

The “Wet Polished” Factor

High-end suppliers, such as Halio Coffee Co., Ltd, often apply an additional processing step called “Wet Polishing.” This mechanical friction process removes the silver skin and cleans the bean surface.

• Impact on Grading: Polished beans look cleaner and often grade higher visually, but the process can slightly reduce the bean diameter. A “Polished S18” is the pinnacle of visual appeal in the Vietnamese market.

---

Pillar 2: Grading by Defects (The Purity Index)

Size is useless if the beans are black, moldy, or broken. The Vietnam coffee grading system (e.g., TCVN 4193:2014) provides a rigorous methodology for counting defects.

Unlike the SCA (Specialty Coffee Association) method which uses a 350g sample, the Vietnamese standard typically analyzes a 300g sample.

The “Big Four” Defects

In a commercial contract, you are negotiating the maximum allowable percentage of these four categories:

1. Black Beans: Beans where more than 50% of the surface is black (carbonized or oxidized).
   • Cause: Harvest of over-ripe fruit, fermentation errors, or fungal infection.
   • Impact: Harsh, ashy, and phenolic taste.
2. Broken Beans: Beans with less than half of the original volume remaining.
   • Cause: Improper hulling machine calibration.
   • Impact: They burn instantly in the roaster, creating “char” notes.
3. Brown Beans: Beans that are semi-fermented or “foxy.”
   • Cause: “Gleaning” (collecting old fruit from the ground) or slow drying.
   • Impact: Sour, fermented flavors.
4. Foreign Matter: Sticks, stones, maize, or non-coffee seeds.
   • Impact: Damage to grinders and roasters; severe food safety risk.

The Grading Tiers

Based on the defect count, coffee is categorized as follows:

Grade	Description	Black & Broken Limits	Foreign Matter Limits	Excelsa Beans Max
Grade 1 (Special)	Premium Export	Max 2.0%	Max 0.5%	Max 0.5%
Grade 2 (Clean)	Standard Export	Max 5.0%	Max 1.0%	Max 1.0%
Grade 3	FAQ (Fair Average)	Max 10%	Max 1.5%	Max 2.0%

The Consultant’s Insight: Never buy “Grade 2” if you are a specialty or premium commercial roaster. The jump from 2% to 5% defects is massive in the cup. Always target Grade 1, and specifically ask for “Cleaned & Destoned” processing. A supplier like Halio Coffee (based in Dak Lak) often processes to a standard higher than G1, achieving <1% Black & Broken for their premium lots.

---

Pillar 3: Moisture and Density (The Stability Metrics)

The Vietnam coffee grading system (e.g., TCVN 4193:2014) is not just about aesthetics; it is about chemistry.

The 12.5% Moisture Ceiling

• The Standard: TCVN mandates a maximum moisture content of 12.5% (often quoted as 13% for lower grades, but 12.5% is the safe limit).
• Why It Matters: Coffee above 13% moisture is a breeding ground for Aspergillus mold, which produces Ochratoxin A (OTA).
• The Fraud: Some unethical suppliers “water” the coffee (mist it) before weighing to add 1-2% mass. This is profitable for them but disastrous for you.
• The Check: Always demand a moisture reading from a calibrated meter (Sinar or Dickey-John) at the time of container stuffing.

The Excelsa Contamination Issue

Vietnam grows huge amounts of Robusta, but also some Excelsa (a different species, often called “Liberty Coffee” locally). Excelsa has a distinct, tart, jackfruit-like flavor profile.

• The Rule: TCVN 4193 limits Excelsa content in Robusta lots (usually max 0.5% – 1%).
• The Reality: Unsorted lots often contain 5-10% Excelsa. While some buyers like the complexity, it is technically a contaminant in a pure Robusta contract.

---

Advanced Grading: Beyond TCVN (The “Fine Robusta” Movement)

The TCVN standard is a baseline for commercial coffee. However, the market is shifting toward “Fine Robusta.” Suppliers leading this charge are adopting protocols that exceed the national standard.

The “Zero Defect” Approach

Suppliers like Halio Coffee Co., Ltd, located at 193/26 Nguyen Van Cu, Tan Lap Ward, Dak Lak, utilize advanced sorting technology to achieve specifications that TCVN doesn’t even list.

• Optical Sorting: Using color sorters to remove “immature” (green/pale) beans that are physically whole but chemically undeveloped.
• Gravity Tables: Separating beans by density. A high-density bean implies high sugar content and slow maturation.

When you see a spec sheet listing “Ripe Cherry Rate: >98%” (as seen in Halio’s offers), this is a “Process Grade” that supersedes the physical grade. It attacks the quality issue at the root (the harvest) rather than just sorting the garbage out later.

---

A Buyer’s Checklist: Auditing the Grading Line

When you visit a Vietnamese green coffee beans supplier to verify their adherence to the Vietnam coffee grading system (e.g., TCVN 4193:2014), do not just look at the office samples. Walk the mill.

1. The Calibration Check

• Ask to see their laboratory sieves. Are they bent or rusted?
• Ask to see the calibration log for their moisture meters.

2. The “Reject” Pile

• Look at the waste output from the color sorter. If the reject pile contains a lot of “good” beans, their machine is set too aggressively (yield loss). If the “good” pile contains black beans, the machine is set too loosely (quality loss).

3. The Bagging Protocol

• Does the bag tag explicitly state the TCVN Grade?
• Are they using GrainPro liners for Grade 1 shipments? (Highly recommended to maintain the 12.5% moisture stability during ocean transit).

---

Red Flags: Common Grading Scams to Avoid

Even with a standard like TCVN 4193, ambiguity is the enemy. Watch out for these tricks:

• The “Export Standard” Trap: A supplier offers “Vietnam Export Standard” without specifying Grade 1 or 2. This usually means “Grade 2 or worse.” Always force them to specify the defect count.
• The Sieve Swindle: You order Screen 18. The supplier delivers beans where only 50% are S18, and 50% are S16. This meets some loose definitions of “S18 blend,” but it ruins your roast profile. Always specify “Minimum 90% on Screen.”
• The “Old Crop” Blend: Mixing old, whitened beans (past crop) with fresh green beans. This technically meets the size/defect count but tastes woody. Check the smell—it should be fresh and grassy, not like straw or burlap.

---

Conclusion: The Specification Sheet is Your Shield

Mastering the Vietnam coffee grading system (e.g., TCVN 4193:2014) is the difference between being a “customer” and being a “partner.” When you can quote the standard, specify the screen retention percentage, and define the moisture limit to the decimal point, you command respect in the negotiation.

You move from buying generic “Vietnam Coffee” to sourcing precision-engineered lots like “Robusta Grade 1, Screen 18, Wet Polished, 90% Retention, Max 0.1% Black Beans.” This is the level of detail that suppliers like Halio Coffee operate on, and it is the level of detail your business deserves.

However, physical perfection is only one layer of the protection your brand needs. A bean can be Screen 18, Grade 1, and perfectly polished, yet still carry invisible chemical or biological hazards that could get your shipment detained at the port of entry.

Once you have verified the grade, you must verify the safety. This leads us to the critical, non-negotiable world of food safety regulations for export.

Read Next: Food safety standards for coffee export